Number of View: 6743

PledgingOne of the top priority of any bread earner is to buy a home and this often comes up with a costly price in the form of a housing loan. Once the loan has been take, the next priority becomes paying the loan off, specially when it comes to Indian culture where running a home loan till its scheduled life is unheard off. People would want to pay it off so that it is one lesser thing to be worried off.

 

We have written an article on Pros and Cons of Home Loan Prepayment and it is heavily commented by the readers. The idea of this post is to further the discussion raised in our earlier post and talk about an interesting option which may convince a few readers to avoid prepaying their loan installments and rather invest their prepayment budgets in an investment vehicle which over the tenure of the loan may result in a multi time more money saving than the interest saved via prepayment.

The idea can be best explained with an example. For the purpose of this article lets assume Chris buys a flat worth Rs. 1 crore in Gurgaon and pays Rs. 25 lacs as initial downpayment. Remaining Rs. 75 lacs is financed by way of home loan which carries an interest rate of 10% over a tenure of 25 years. Monthly mortgage (home loan emi) comes to Rs. 68,153.

CASE A : If Chris continues to repay Rs. 68K per month towards the home loan for the entire tenure of the loan for 25 years, he would have paid 300 monthly installments. Over 25 years he would have paid Rs. 1.29 crores as interest to the bank and his total outflow would be Rs. 2.04 crores for a loan amount of Rs. 75 lacs.

CASE B : Chris decides that he would want to get rid of the loan at the earliest as he doesn’t like the idea of paying Rs. 1.29 crores as interest to the bank towards a loan of Rs. 75 lacs. He pre-pays Rs. 15K per month in addition to his monthly mortgage installments of Rs. 68K. His total monthly outflow is Rs. 83K and he finishes his loan off in 168 installments. He pays 64 lacs towards interest and his total outflow including interest towards loan repayment is Rs. 1.39 crores. He saved paying interest of Rs. 64 lacs by choosing prepayment option. Smart ? Would you choose this option as well ?

Interest Savings

 

John also took a similar property of same value on same interest terms. His home loan terms were exactly same as Chris i.e. 10% p.a. for 10 years. However, instead of prepaying the amount to the bank, he chose to invest Rs. 15K per month in mutual funds for 14 years (168 months). For next 14 years, his monthly cash flows were as follows :

1. Paying loan installments : Rs. 68,153

2. Investing in Mutual Funds : Rs. 15,000.

After 14 years (168 months) John’s financial situation is summarized in the table below.

John’s investment in Mutual funds would have grown to Rs. 84.72 lacs if his investments grew at 15% per year. Since he did not pre-pay his loan like Chris, his outstanding loan balance after 168 months (14 years) is Rs. 54 lacs (row 2 in the table below).  He can now sell his investments of Rs. 84.72 lacs and pay off his entire loan of Rs. 54 lacs and still be left with Rs. 30 lacs.. Nice ? If he was more luckier with his investments growing at 18% per year, he may be left with Rs. 57 lacs instead of Rs. 30 lacs after paying off his loan.

Interest Invested via SIP

 

Now let me leave this question with you to ponder.

Who is smarter in managing his finances ? Is it Chris who regularly prepaid his loan and completely settled his loan by 168th month ? Or is it John who chose not to prepay the loan but rather invest the amount of his prepayment budget in a mutual fund which grew faster than the interest saving he could have made should he have acted like Chris. After all he was left with a handsome Rs. 30 lacs even after paying his loan off at the same time as Chris !

Related Posts:

11 Responses to Should I Prepay my Loan Or Invest Till End of Tenure

  1. Atul says:

    The following analysis is based on prediction that equities will be giving 15% or 18%. A better approach could be to prepay till interest and principal form equal parts of an EMI and then stop prepayment. There after invest amount marked for prepacment in equities.

  2. Hi Atul,
    That’s correct. I 15% from Equity markets too much of an ask over a tenure of 14 years ? I am not sure how would your approach be more beneficial. By prepaying any amount, max what you will save is the interest cost of ~10%. However, the opportunity loss is 15% over the duration of loan.

  3. This is again on assumption of 15% return from equities which may or may not happen. Monetarily there is a 50% chance of gain. However, a housing loan is always a pondering issue for salary dependent employees in current scenario. I would say chuck it out as early as possible so you are free to do whatever you like without worrying about monthly commitments.

  4. Narayanamurthi,
    It all depends upon how you look at it. 15% returns from equities over the duration of home loan is not a 50% chance but closer to 90%-100% chance. History can prove it, provided you maintain patience as you will be doing in case of a LIC policy of 15 years.

  5. Bhaskar says:

    Mutual fund is very risky and market linked. The above gain of 15% can turn to 0% also if market gets crashed.

  6. rama says:

    what are the sources to invest money less amount (i.e around ,5000/- to 10,000/-) which is safe investment getting high returns

  7. drwef says:

    how can we invest in mutual funds

  8. Narender says:

    hi ,i took home loan of 25 Lacs inJanuary 2016 .till the date i repaid 7 x 26000=1.82 Lacs …but principal amount reduced only 35 k ….if i continue with EMI i have to pay almost double of Loan amount …..but i got a help from my family for partial payment amounting like 3 0r 4 lacs……please advise is it really helpfull to make partial payment or to invest this amount in other equities ……

  9. Hi Narender, the following article will help you take the decision.

    http://insight.banyanfa.com/home-loan-prepayment/

  10. Please contact us at info@banyanfa.com with your contact details and we can talk it through.

  11. Rama,
    Best source to invest lesser amounts is via Mutual Funds. Please read our article http://insight.banyanfa.com/what-is-a-mutual-fund/ for more details.

Leave a Reply

Set your Twitter account name in your settings to use the TwitterBar Section.
Close
Would you consider liking our page ?
We provide regular updates on our Twitter, Facebook and Google plus pages to help our followers financially. You may click the buttons below to get updates.
Web Design MymensinghPremium WordPress ThemesWeb Development

Delhi – Odd Vs Even Formula

January 2, 2016January 2, 2016

The actual success of the Delhi government’s odd-even formula will be known only by January 15, but if the response of most Delhiities on the first day is any indicator, then the risk taken by Arvind Kejriwal’s Aam Aadmi Party seems to have paid off.

The local government will review the effect on pollution after the 15-day trial and consider including two-wheelers in the second phase of the scheme.

For more click here